Thursday, 6 June 2013

FOOD SECURITY BILL, ERADICATION OF STARVATION IN INDIA



After a wait of 63 long years. Government is thinking of taking responsibility of feeding its starving people. The word thinking, I am using here knowingly. Because as wide is the ambit of the food security bill, more then that is the process and procedure. How government is going to implement it. Implementation part is raising so many doubts. Looking to the credibility of the government, its agencies and contractors, it looks almost impossible. It is almost sure that after a span of 3-4 years we are going to listen the same thing, starvation deaths, undernourishment, Corores of rupees are gulped by those who were entrusted responsibility of its implementation. It is really tough. We have experienced miserable failure of FDS. It is the same government who was crying, for the amount of subsidy in this head. It is really eighth wonder of the world, the same government, the same head of the government, with thorough knowledge of economics is ready to share this burden of subsidy, going to cost Rs. 3067 Corores.  Even then the ambit and provisions of the bill are going to have such a wide impact on the majority population of the country, that no political party can dare to neglect it. Yes it is prime duty of any government to take care of primary needs of its people, in these primary needs, food security comes at first. It is important for any government to save its poor masses from the effect of inflation causing starvation.

How ever it is important to see, how provisions of this proposed bill are going to be implemented. It needs lot of home work. Any haste in this direction is ultimately going to ruin poor masses who are going to be most benefited. Because failure of the bill will give rulers of the country an excuse to say that such type of experiments are not fiisible. And it will put a break on other so many issues, required to be implemented in future. This bill, how ever good and important it may be, have several social problems hidden in it. It is also time to gauge and look for solutions of these problems. It is not the question of any particular political party. It is a national issue. Needs to be handled with care. Not only all political parties, but social organisations also have an important role to play in successful implementation of this bill.

Coming to the provisions of the bill, states have a mega role to play. Almost most of the burden is transferred on the states. Right from procurement of food grains to storage of it, transportation and distribution is going to be another big work of the states. The success of the bill is largely depend on states, they have to bear 30% cost, rest 70% cost is born by the center, state- center relationship will play a major role in it, apart from it state have to recognize 46% to 90% population in the rural and 28% to 90% population in the urban area, they have to maintain record of it and to distribute food grains to it. Only distribution of the food grains is not the only duty to be performed by the states, beside several other measures require to curb starvation and undernourishment states have to play a role in making arrangement of distribution of cooked meals. This cooked meal is to be distributed to the homeless population. Major issue is that several states are providing food grains at subsidized rates to the people presently. And these schemes of the states have provoked center to bring this legislation. What will happen to these schemes. In fact it is not and should not be the matter of taking credit for any political party, it is primary duty of, not only the state but also of every well off citizen to get such type of scheme implemented successfully. It needs lot of discussion and ground work. Which is absent. 

Don't know whether these various problems and their solutions are also in mind, while proceeding for this bill.
Because implementation of MANREGA got some criticism, of not finding laborers. Though these problems can not be an excuse for implementation of poor pro schemes, but balance should be maintained. This is not in vision. What will happen to the industries and other productive work fields. Will they continue to receive work force, at their work place. If YES at what cost. How this is going to effect growth rate, GDP of the nation. We all are aware of the beggars population in the country, how this population is going to behave. How our leaders will  understand that It is not a subject of 2014 elections, but connected with the eradication of starvation from the land, which is a great social abuse to any nation. Needs to be addressed jointly. Present circumstances are only indicating, half hearted efforts, probably with a view, that we are not going to come in power in 2014, why not create big hurdles for those coming to power. Believe it or not, preparations of the government in connection with this bill is the indication, that the regime for the political party coming to power is going to create havoc for them.  
 

Tuesday, 4 June 2013

REAL ESTATE BILL NOT SHAPED PROPERLY


Real Estate Regulation Bill discussed in cabinet meeting is just an eye wash, without teeth and incomplete legislation as it appears from the draft of the bill. Though it is a replica of Consumer Protection Act, it is going to increase miseries instead of protecting interest of the consumers. It seems that the bill is brought in haste, several important points are not covered in the scope of the Bill. Lot of amendments are required in the draft Bill, if govt. really want to look in to the 
grievances of the consumers in reality estate sector. Role of consumer organisations is completely ignored in this bill. Whereas they should have been given weightage over individuals. We Akhil Bhartiya Grahak Panchayat with a large experience in the field know, how the consumers are getting cheated. We are not able to see, solution of those problems in the bill.

Definition Section 2 of the bill, is unable to include consumer organisations as a person. Now a days only consumer organisations are helping consumers in getting reliefs, either by mutual understandings or in the consumer courts. 
Important role of consumer organisations can not be ignored, it should be included as a person in definition section.

Similarly "DISPUTE","COMPLAINANT" & "COMPLAINT FILING PROCEDURE""CONSUMER ORGANISATION is absent from this section 2, are not defined. And is a must,  who and how one will go before regulatory authority is in dark. The definition of above mentioned words is necessary.

Section 15(1)b of the Bill deals with the case of failure of the promoter in giving possession or flat/building to the consumer. Remedy is given that the promoter will refund the amount with interest. This open ways for the promoters in getting rid from the consumers, in today's market, where prices in the reality sector are on the rise every day. Promoter will not be pained in refunding money with the interest. But poor consumer have to forget, purchasing any similar accommodation, because of escalating costs. The promoter should be made liable to give similar accommodation to the consumer as he has booked or possession of the plot should be given to the group of consumers of the dwelling unit, so that they themselves can get their apartment constructed, at proportionate cost. 

Section 19 is about, who can become member of the authority. All government servants are excluded except secretaries. Why secretaries, it should also be deleted from this section.

Section 30 is about amicable solutions. Consumer association having experience in the field are ignored, instead appointment of persons, officers suggested. Consumer organisations like Akhil Bhartiya Grahak Panchayat has sorted out thousands of disputes, till now amicably, even when this act is not in existence. Consumer organisations can play a great role in this field. Therefore role of Consumer organisations should be inserted in this section, with a remark of giving them preference over others. Definitely care should be taken in selection of the consumer organisations with credentials. It is also important to give preference to organisations over individuals, because involvement of organisations will restrict malpractices.

Section 48, constitution of advisory council, participation of consumer organisation is also not addressed properly in this section. Five bodies are selected to give 10 members, participation of consumer organisations should be increased here also.

Again section 50 penalties clause is unable to accommodate, alternative accommodation of similar description in similar area, it should be included.

The draft is approved by the cabinet, needs much more corrections, other then discussed above. It will be better if a group discussion is organised before introducing it in parliament. Suggestions should be asked from different segment of the people. 



Saturday, 18 May 2013

BIRTH OF CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT IN INDIA


  It is more then 30 years,We are working for welfare of consumers in India. Initially we tried to unite consumers. Raised voice in government and business circles where ever the consumers are not treated fairly. Because at that time there was no legislation for the welfare of consumers. We then concentrated at this. We formed a legal committee at Nagpur, Mr. Ghanshyamdas Mundhada was president of this committee. After several meetings, prepared a draft of consumer protection act. Later on this bill was introduced in the parliament, as a private member bill. Mr. Rambhau Mhlangi,Jansangh(MP) had introduced this bill. Height of this is that, and a rare example of Indian Politics, how political parties keep their political interests away, when it comes to the welfare of people. Rambhau Mhlangi, Jansangh, MP and Banatwala, Muslim League MP, both join hands and this resulted in this Private Member Bill in the interest of consumers. This bill contain signature of both as introducer and seconder. This bill could not see the light of day, because of sad demise of Mr. Mhlangi.

  Later on when Mr. Rajiv Gandhi joined politics. He was on visit to wardha, spent some time at Nagpur. Mr. Vilas Muttemwar Congress MP, accompanied Raja Bhau Pophali, ex President Akhil Bhartiya Grahak Panchayat to Mr. Gandhi. Mr. Pophali discussed interests of Consumer, and that the efforts of Grahak Panchayat, for getting a legislation. Mr. Gandhi assured, after  returning asked Mr, Hari Kishan Lal Bhagat, the then minister for food and civil supplies. The bill was introduced as a government bill and Consumer Protection Act 1986 came in existence.

Wednesday, 15 May 2013

CONSUMER FORCED TO COUGH MONEY ON PETROLEUM - COURTESY GOVT.

It is true, that consumers are forced to cough unreasonable money for Petroleum products, courtesy government. It has become very common every now and then, that the prices of Petrol, Diesel and LPG are hiked, in the name of fluctuating rates of crude oil in the international market. It is true that crude rates are fluctuating. But it is not correct to say that out of this fluctuation only Government is forced to increase prices of petroleum products. 

 The move of the government is very calculated. They try to create an atmosphere in the media that because of rise in international crude price, they are scumming under the burden of subsidy. And increase in the prices in inevitable. Which is not true. In fact, they are making the consumers to cough out, whatever subsidy they pay on these products by imposing huge tax at different stages. This is all gimmicky. At one hand government poses that they are taking care of the consumers and bearing the heavy burden of subsidy, they advertise it in media and through so called expert. They create an atmosphere, shows concern. At the other hand they take back entire money of subsidy, even more by way of heavy taxation from the consumers. In absence of pricing policy credentials of the government are doubtful. If they are really concerned for the consumers. They should immediately make and publish fair and transparent pricing policy for the petroleum products. 

 Several times Grahak Panchayat requested the government to absorb international hike in crude price by reducing heavy tax they have imposed on consumers. But since it is going to spoil their game of posing as pro consumer government. If the government is heavily burdened of the subsidy. Instead of authorizing the Oil Companies to decide prices of the petroleum products. Why they are not bringing transparency in the system. Why they are not declaring pricing policy.Why they are keeping it secret. 

 We have some data to show how petroleum prices works - 

Crude price in international market few days back US$ 93.75 per barrel 
 It comes to Rs. 5128.12 (93.75 X 54.70 rupees exchange rate) 
 1 barrel = 158.76 liter 
 Crude oil price per liter comes Rs.32.30 
 Refining cost per liter. Rs. 0.52 
 Capital cost to refinery Rs. 6.00 
 Cost of Transportation Rs. 6.00 
 Dealers Commission Rs. 1.05 
 Total Price of petrol/ liter comes Rs. 45.87 

Huge amount of tax levied by the government forces consumer to purchase petrol at Rs.63.09 in Delhi to Rs.71.22 in Nagpur. 

These taxes are levied by government in the name of Custom Duty, Excise Duty, Special Excise Duty, Education Cess, Sales Tax, State Cess and Octrai. 

 Elections of loksabha are due in 2014. Consumers of the country ask the political parties to clear their stand on the issue.

Friday, 19 April 2013

AGAIN IT HAPPENED TO GUDIA IN DELHI, WHERE IS THE SOLUTION


Once again protests are going on in Delhi demanding justice for crime against minor. Strict law is there, police machinery is there.Where is the solution, can addition of death penalty in the law is the solution. I do not think so. Was this matter is taken seriously by the police or the government unless protests started. Therefore where is the solution in the law or accountability. Has the police or government acted in time, perhaps the girl could have been rescued unhurt. Off course strong law is required, but is not the final solution for such social crimes.

Today crises is not of law, it is of accountability. If we want solution, we have to make both society and police accountable.Take the incident of Jaipur, how society acted. One can easily say that may be because, society feels that if they come forward, police will entangle them in the matter. This is where we need amendments in the law and its implementation procedures.How an important part of the system Police and Government can be so much insensitive that it waited for 3 days to act unless protests started. It is time for action, not of theoretical solutions. And action comes from accountability. Mere suspension of police officers that too with the fear of strong protests can not justify it. In case police felt that they are accountable perhaps this brutality may not have happened and Gudia could have been saved. 

It is time a debate should be started, not for change of law, but how Government, Police and Society can be made accountable for the crime taking place around. It is time for ACTION not of THEORETICAL SOLUTIONS.  

Thursday, 18 April 2013

CONSUMER MOVEMENT - BEYOND SALE & PURCHASE


Unfortunate part of the consumer movement in the world is that it is viewed as tool to provide  commodities and services to the consumers in good condition. He is equipped with a mechanism of getting justice in case he feels exploited, to sort out his grievances.

Unlike other countries of the world. We have a legislation in India. It provides cheap and speedy justice to the consumers through a special quasi judicial system.If consumer feels that he is not provided, what he is promised for a price he has paid. And the seller fails to give any solution to his grievances. He can approach consumer judicial system for sorting out his grievances. Consumer movement of the world is restricted to this approach only.

But to restrict consumer movement to this is not fair for consumer interests. We can stop consumer exploitation with this limited approach.Consumer is  the nuclea of the economic world. For healthy economy healthy consumer is the basic requirement. He has to play an important role for healthy economic built up. Unfortunately he is pushed on the fence and in the name of consumer movement only shallow activities are in existence. 

We want to build healthy market and healthy economy, It can not be achieved without consumer participation. Consumer should be given representation in Production, distribution, quality certification and price fixation of goods and services. Economy of a nation is based on the money collected from the consumers in the form of various taxes.Whenever consumer purchases any thing , he pays tax in one or other form. And tax collected so is spent by the government for various schemes of consumer welfare. In other word we can say Financial Budget of the government comes out of it.  How unfortunate it is that consumer is never asked for his priorities, coming out of the money he has paid. Consumer movement should be aimed to it. We know it is very difficult task, almost impossible to achieve. But to make it possible let us start by reminding every consumer that what ever he is seeing or getting around, has come out of the money he has paid while making any purchase in the market. And that he has every right to ask for the money spent. This should be the starting point.No doubt, We are going to get exploitation free environment.

Wednesday, 17 April 2013

'MRP' - TOOL FOR CONSUMER EXPLOITATION!


  • Maximum Retail Price (MRP) is a tool used to extort exorbitant money from consumers. Government in conspiracy with the trading community implemented it to give impression to the consumers that their interests are taken care off, where as it is totally false.
  • Consumers are under the impression that MRP printed on the products is controlled by the Government. Truth is that manufacturers are free to print any amount in the name of MRP. There are no guidelines or formula given by the government, which can restrict trading community to print the relevant MRP.
  • How consumer interests can be protected in absence of a government guide line - by calculating how much profit one can add in their Production Cost, for writing MRP. In absence of any such mechanism, Trading community is making the consumer's to cough out more money and exploiting them by projecting that MRP is the price fixed by the Government.